Phoenix Permaculture Guild

Join us in creating a more sustainable Phoenix!

Is there a easily accessed resource or reference that discusses MiracleGro's long-term effect on soil and the watershed?
thanks!

Share Twitter

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

davesgarden.com/guides/terms/go/2307/ I was also curious about the long term effects of using MiraclGro so did a little web searching and found the site mentioned above. Hope this helps shed some light on reasons for not using it. I guess I'll get rid of mine. Never thought with all the hype that it was a bad thing to use. Darn. Live and learn. (Not sure if the last back slash is necessary in the web address but you can play with it if it doesn't work to copy and paste it)

Reply to This

Not going to say good or bad things about MiraclGro, but Davesgarden is a site aimed at people that do not live in the desert like we do. Doing something to acidify your soil here is a good thing, just not so much in a wetter climate. Here we have a very high ph and it needs to be acidified to make most garden vegetables happier and healthier. Much of the stress I have seen plants under have been because of high soil ph.

Reply to This

I guess my concern is really the chemical makeup of MiracleGro. You're absolutely right on about the need for AZ soil to have a little added acidity for some plants and that side of the product doesn't concern me. I would just advise users to do the research and then decide for themselves.

Reply to This

I was not really replying to any claims or anything about MiracleGro rather about the soil here is very much in need of a lower ph, the better way of doing this is by applying ground sulfur to the soil, as this is a natural, and organic listed material.
The only problem I saw was Dave's site makes sweeping statements about the soil which some of are not true for this area of the world. People really do grow things in different areas than where he lives.:)
It really goes to your comment about people need to do some research about materials and decide what they want as individuals.

Reply to This

RSS

Support the Guild

EcoMania

Botanical Interests, Inc.

Latest Activity

Biltmore area.
23 minutes ago
Trini added a discussion
I missed the tree chippers coming through my area, and I have to get rid of this Christmas tree before my neighbors call the HOA 5-0s.Do you have a chipper, other means of recycling a tree, or a good idea for me?I can deliver it.Thanks,Markmarktrini…
1 hour ago
Deb Bailly is attending Christy Grace's event
March 20, 2010 from 9am to 11am
Don has been "living" permaculture and sustainability for several years. His environment is a testament to the many ingenious ways he's incorporated sustainability into his life. See veggie and flower gardens, urban chickens, bees, water harvesting,…
1 hour ago
Sorry about the mix up on the date...This will be held on the evening of April 7. I am still working on securing a space for the event. thanks, Jeff
1 hour ago
Thank you, Judy. That is a lot closer to my house. I'll probably head out this weekend to pick some up.
1 hour ago
Here is a link to a search tool for Mastergardeners. It will not tell you if the fruit is edible, but it does say what type of wildlife it will attract. These plants also have the benefit of being desert adapted, so you are not spending a ton of mon…
2 hours ago
Actually there is a local company that sells them for 18.98. They are 25' with a 9" diameter. I am thinking of getting them for my school garden project. It is going to take a couple of years to turn our dirt into soil and this allows the instant gr…
3 hours ago
Erin, we subscribed to Desert Roots CSA a couple of years ago, don't think they offered meat then but I'll check it out, thanks.
4 hours ago

2009 Arizona Farmers' Market List

Proud member of:

© 2010   Created by Administrator

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service